Harold McElmurry, 29, and Vickie McElmurry, 24, were driving a car that belonged to murder victims Robert and Vivian Pendley, investigators said. sharing the stories, pictures and loves of Oklahomans across our great state. This week, we look into the sleepy town of Eufaula, Oklahoma, where a down on their luck, and meth addled couple hatch an ill conceived plan that leads to a brutal double murder. However, a jury acquitted him of the charges and two months later, he died of a heart attack. "If you think it was frustrating for us, you know it's frustrating for the family because thats your loved one and you want to know what happened to them," says Morris. Shannon Agofsky is on death row at a federal prison in Terra Haute, Indiana, for the stomping death of an inmate while incarcerated in a Texas prison. Records show Vickie McElmurry, also known as Vickie Lynn Holman, is on probation for two Muskogee County property crimes. Happy Birthday from Columbus Corner Bakery! Prosecutors say they will retry him. Suspect Charged With Murder In Death Of Eufaula Man. Both were sentenced to death, but the Court of Criminal Appeals overturned the sentences in 1992. EUFAULA, Ala. (WRBL) - A Saturday afternoon shooting in the area of South Randolph Avenue in Eufaula claimed the life of one man and left another seriously injured. ! Select your ideal criteria and let Scout do the rest. A few pieces of the Pendleys' jewelry were found with the McElmurrys, investigators said. Eufaula police received a 911 call reporting a domestic assault at Chattahoochee Courts Apartments at approximately 2:24 a.m. on Aug. 10. Pastor Jack Perkins told mourners that no one can rob the Pendleys' loved ones of the joy they derived from knowing the victims. Local and federal officials continue to investigate as the community awaits answers. Williams was sentenced to death for Rogers' murder and remains on death row after the U.S. Supreme Court rejected his final appeal earlier this month. Texas fugitive accused of murder arrested in South 9 hours ago. Norris was shot and died, Weber said. 7,043,501 and 7,680,859. The Customs Service said a wheelchair - apparently one used by the paraplegic Robert Pendley - was in the car trunk. Chambers, a former high school cheerleader, died from her injuries. A death sentence for the McElmurrys would be just fine with Arthur Roy Kirkpatrick, Vivian Pendley's younger brother. Getaway driver Christopher Jordan was sentenced to 15 years in prison. She pleaded guilty in February 1998 to forgery and receiving stolen property and received a three-year deferred sentence. . IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, A police officer walks to his car in front of the Bank of Eufaula, where two people were shot, one fatally, on Thursday. Property crimes are motor vehicle theft, arson, larceny, and burglary. One victim, with multiple gunshot wounds was transported by Eufaula Rescue to Medical Center Barbour. Dec. 14, 1984: Jay Wesley Neill, 19, and Robert Grady Johnson, 22, executed four people and injured three others during a robbery at the First Chattanooga Bank in Geronimo. Crime risk data are updated annually. MONTGOMERY, Ala. (WSFA) - The Alabama Law Enforcement Agency's State Bureau of Investigation has arrested and charged a suspect in connection to the . In the I live here in Eufaula for a reason, and thats scary that something like that would happen here in this small town we call home, Harris said. A $30,000 reward is still being offered for information leading to the killer's arrest. It appeared the family had disappeared into thin air. Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device. McElmurry, 24, and her husband, Harold Loyd McElmurry, 29, made their first court appearance Wednesday in the beating and stabbing deaths of an elderly couple. He's due back in court January 26, 2017, at 9 a.m. Be among the first to get breaking news, weather, and general news updates from News on 6 delivered right to your inbox! They were there real fast. of Hitchita, was charged Friday with accessory to first-degree murder in the death of Ronnie Crenshaw, 64, of . Woman charged with murder in Eufaula stabbing From staff reports Aug 11, 2019 Aug 11, 2019 Updated Jul 15, 2020; 0; Eufaula Police Department Facebook; Twitter; WhatsApp; SMS; Email; Print . We promise to never spam you. They were. The Criminal Investigations Division is conducting the ongoing investigation. The investigation is still ongoing, and developments are happening daily, said Detective Kevin Branscum, MCSO K9 Narcotics/Supervisor. Neill was executed in December 2002. You can opt-out at any time. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, A police dog and its handler are among the law enforcement officials from multiple agencies at the site of a fatal shooting in McIntosh County on Thursday. The intent seems to be a bank robbery, in an odd way, he said. The unsolved killings have become one of Oklahoma's most notorious cold cases. I talked to the husband and son and they were both very grateful and thankful and seemed almost in tears, you know," says Morris. Prosecutors told Associate District Judge Gene Mowery that they will seek the death penalty, said John Remington, an investigator with the Oklahoma Indigent Defense System. "They looked like they'd been through hell," said J.M. Ultimately, Morris says his department took the case to a grand jury to subpoena witnesses. "I don't know if they were trying to bluff their way through, or what," Martinez said. It would be wonderful if they called us and said, This is it, Becky Patty, Libertys grandmother, told PEOPLE in September. The shock of losing everyone really tore up our town, Freeman said. Neighbors told the News On 6 they heard people yelling at each other followed by gunshots and when they looked outside, they saw the home on fire. Violent Crime Comparison (per 1,000 residents), Property Crime Comparison (per 1,000 residents). Violent Small Town Murder #024 - Bad Decisions, Deadly Results in Eufaula, Oklahoma Episode Summary This week, we look into the sleepy town of Eufaula, Oklahoma, where a down on their luck, and meth addled couple hatch an ill conceived plan that leads to a brutal double murder. James Carl Wivell, 48, of Longmont, Colorado, was killed when his truck overturned while he was trying to avoid hitting Dishmons wrecked car. EUFAULA - Two suspects in the beating and stabbing deaths of an elderly couple confessed Friday after they were caught trying to cross back into Texas from Mexico, authorities said. sharing the stories, pictures and loves of Oklahomans across our great state. "The judge was kind enough to inform us of their (prosecutors') intention," Remington said. VIDEO: Robbery Rocks Small Town Eufaula EUFAULA The Bank of Eufaula's president was fatally shot and the gunman was killed after a subsequent police pursuit Thursday morning in McIntosh. Along the way, we find out exactly how hard it is to escape to Mexico, how much worm dung one would need to farm to make a living, and how easy it seems to be . sharing the stories, pictures and loves of Oklahomans across our great state. Prosecutors charged William Brown with first-degree murder. Thursday, December 29th 2016, 4:49 pm. Crime, My Chances of Becoming a Victim of a That day, all three of them mysteriously . I know it's a relief for the family. Prosecutors haven't filed the required notice of intent to seek the death penalty, "but everybody kind of expected this after these people were arrested for the crime," Remington said. Roughly similar to the national average, our analysis shows that your chance of becoming a victim of violent crime in Eufaula is one in 917. The second gunshot victim was airlifted for further evaluation and treatment. McIntosh County prosecutors charged the McElmurrys with first-degree murder on Friday, four days after the Pendleys' bodies were found in their garage 10 miles west of Eufaula. 10/14/2017 Related Story:Suspect Arrested In Eufaula Man's Death. Driver In Deadly Hit-And-Run Identified By Tulsa Police, Tulsa Police Shoot, Kill Man Accused Of Breaking Into Home, Firing At Officers, Wagoner Officers Recognized For Saving People From Fentanyl Overdoses, Tulsa Kindergarteners Create And Record Song About The City. EUFAULA The Bank of Eufaulas president was fatally shot and the gunman was killed after a subsequent police pursuit Thursday morning in McIntosh County, authorities said. Joseph Agofsky died in a federal prison in 2013 at the age of 46. Neither Remington nor Assistant District Attorney Phil Cozzoni would say whether either defendant plans to testify against the other. 2 News reached out to the Cantrell family and they are requesting privacy at this time. Best friends Abigail "Abby" Williams and Liberty "Libby" German were enjoying a nature walk early in 2017 when things took a terrible turn. Hogan said he notified the Pendley family of the arrests shortly before the victims' funeral Friday morning. Streets in the area were blocked for most of the day Thursday. Raw crime incidents are sourced from all 18,000+ local law enforcement agencies municipal, county, transit, park, port, university, tribal and more, assigned to localities, then built into NeighborhoodScouts proprietary predictive models to provide a comprehensive crime risk profile for every neighborhood and address-vicinity in the U.S. More about NeighborhoodScouts crime data methodology, By sending this Report you agree to NeighborhoodScout's, My Chances of Becoming a Victim of a The man is identified as 34-year-old Trevor Armstrong. Shannon Agofsky was convicted in Oklahoma of Shorts death, but jurors failed to convict Joseph Agofsky for the death and prosecutors declined to try him a second time. Kirkpatrick said he made eye contact once with Vickie McElmurry. EUFAULA The president of the Bank of Eufaula was shot and killed and another bank employee wounded Thursday by a Texas man during a robbery. Weber said both women who were shot have undergone surgery and likely will survive. It has been called Dr. Seuss Day because of this. Two years after the murders, police arrested John Peel, who worked for Mark. She continued to the third flood of the garage, unlocked her car, a Ford Escape, and heard a noise behind her. Martin, 21, went missing in September and investigators found his body . The assailant then approached a teller, from whom he took an undisclosed amount of money. Kirkpatrick said he wishes the McElmurrys would receive something "like in the old times - hanging, the electric chair or gas.". You can cancel at any time. The slaying of skipper Mark Coulthurst and his pregnant wife, Irene, both 28, along with their children Kimberly, 5, and John, 4, and four deckhands Chris Heyman, 18; and Keown, Moon and Mike Stewart, all 19 is still Alaskas worst unsolved mass homicide. Martin, 21, went missing in September and investigators found his. The victim told police that he and his girlfriend had been walking from the front of an apartment building in the 300 block of East 11th Stree, Leeroy Wendell McQueary II, 40, of Tulsa faces up to 10 years in prison when he is sentenced for assaulting two Saint Francis Hospital securit. On Monday, Pittsburg County Sheriff's Office arrested 36-year-old Cody Ketchum.. Sign up for our newsletter to keep reading. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, Eufaula Police Officer Brain Martin stands behind police tape at the Bank of Eufaula, where the bank president was fatally shot and another employee was injured on Thursday. Authorities have said they believe she tried to identify her killer as she burned. Please subscribe to keep reading. his wife Sherilynn, and their six-year-old daughter Madyson were living what appeared to be normal lives in Eufaula, Okla. until Oct. 8, 2009. Get the Android Weather app from Google Play, New Executive Chef joins Columbus Convention & Trade, SoftVuescreening is lifesaving for the 40% of, CDL operator shortage impacts METRA Transit of Columbus, University System of Georgia names finalist for CSU, Taylor County, Hardaway Girls advance to GHSA Final, CCSD announces two-hour delayed start on Thursday, Pacelli Beats Brookstone in Elite 8, Advances to, Spencer beats Butler, Advances to Elite Eight, Carver, Hardaway Girls advance to GHSA Elite Eight, CPD searching for missing teen last seen on Caspian, Super Bowl Champion shares passion for reading, Heated 2 hours of public agenda draws crowds at City. I wish I had not let her go, Lori's mother told PEOPLE. The chance of becoming a victim of either violent or property crime in Eufaula is 1 in 55. Victims Identified In Eufaula Homicide, Fire, Oklahoma Sports Moments: Nebraska 7, Oklahoma 3 - 1988, Oklahoma's Sports Moments: Jason White Highlights (Part 2), Driver In Deadly Hit-And-Run Identified By Tulsa Police, Tulsa Police Shoot, Kill Man Accused Of Breaking Into Home, Firing At Officers, Wagoner Officers Recognized For Saving People From Fentanyl Overdoses, Tulsa Kindergarteners Create And Record Song About The City. Martinez said the McElmurrys have decided to waive extradition and will appear before a Webb County judge this morning. [2] Their suspected remains were found in November 2013 and positively identified by the Oklahoma medical examiner on July 3, 2014. Person of interest in Okmulgee murder case found in Florida, DOWNLOAD the 2 News Oklahoma app for alerts, Bixby Public Schools hosting first Teachers Night Out, Okmulgee community reacts to murder investigation. Nearly 300 people packed the First Baptist Church of Eufaula. June 22, 2004: Masked gunmen Jeremy Alan Williams and Alvin Tony Jordan robbed the First Fidelity Bank at 2642 E. 21st St., gunning down bank employee Amber Rogers and wounding the bank's president and a customer. 27, 2021 at 3:17 PM PDT. Ive seen people die, but Ive never seen a more horrific way to die than what I saw today, Simpson told The Oklahoman. Other US patent applications are currently pending. Newson6.com is proud to provide Oklahomans with timely and relevant news and information, Train Station in 1983: How New Fingerprint Technology Led to Arrest, How a Killer Massacred an Entire Family on a Fishing Boat in Alaska and Was Never Caught, PEOPLE Explains: The Mystery of Who Massacred 8, Including a Family, on Fishing Boat in Alaska, Robert Durst Charged with Murder of First Wife, Who Disappeared in 1982, How a Slain Teen Known as 'Horseshoe Harriet' Was ID'd Decades After Her Murder by a Serial Killer, Self-Proclaimed Serial Killer Sentenced to Death in Oklahoma for 1997 Murder of Newlywed Teen, Exonerated Suspect in Unsolved Alaska Fishing Boat Mass Murder Breaks His Silence, 40 Years After 3 Girl Scouts Were Killed at Camp, Police Hope DNA Will Reveal Their Killer. Store employees then called the police, she said. Listen to this episode from Small Town Murder on Spotify. Prosecutors charged William Brown with first-degree murder. The grand jury eventually indicted Ketchum once enough evidence was gathered. This is a small town. Oct. 6, 1989: Joseph and Shannon Agofsky abducted bank president Dan Short from his home in rural Benton County, Arkansas, and drove him to the State Bank of Noel, Missouri, where he was forced to open the vault and the brothers stole about $71,000. We promise to never spam you. Discuss Eufaula, Oklahoma (OK) on our hugely popular Oklahoma forum. It's the worst thing I've seen in approximately 31 years," said Bertie County Sheriff John Holley. Some parts 2023 Advameg, Inc. Crime rate in Eufaula, Oklahoma (OK): murders, rapes, robberies, assaults, burglaries, thefts, auto thefts, arson, law enforcement employees, police officers, crime map. City-data.com does not guarantee the accuracy or timeliness of any information on this site. Use at your own risk. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, A person inside the Bank of Eufaula covers the windows after two people were shot there Thursday. "It looks like we werent doing anything but it just takes time to do it right.. Be among the first to get breaking news, weather, and general news updates from News on 6 delivered right to your inbox! "The family wanted it to be an uplifting time," Perkins said later. This is possible by associating the 9.4 million reported crimes in the U.S, including over 2 million geocoded point locations. 1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. Eufaula Crime Data Crime Index 25 (100 is safest) Safer than 25% of U.S. Cities Eufaula Annual Crimes Violent Crime Violent Crime Comparison (per 1,000 residents) 20 15 10 5 0 1.09 4.42 National Median: 4 Eufaula Oklahoma My Chances of Becoming a Victim of a Violent Crime 1 in 917 in Eufaula 1 in 226 in Oklahoma Eufaula VIOLENT CRIMES Neither defendant entered a plea Wednesday. They'd been killed in a homicide. IAN MAULE/Tulsa World, A hand can be seen at the top of the left window as someone places a sheet or paper over the windows at the Bank of Eufaula, where two people were shot Thursday morning. . Police later discovered that Liberty, 14, had taken pictures and videos on her phone of an unidentified man authorities believe is the suspect in her and 13-year-old Abigail's deaths. Authorities said the man who shot two people in a Eufaula bank, killing one, led police on a car chase that ended in the assailant's being fatally shot and his hostage injured. In October, a mistrial was declared in the murder trial of Chambers' acquaintance Quinton Tellis, 29, who was arrested in 2016 after an extensive investigation and who has maintained his innocence. Martinez said the McElmurrys told him they had been in Mexico for three days. He was then convicted in Tulsa County in 2006 of second-degree robbery and in Creek County in 2007 of malicious injury to property, records show. She said law enforcement officers swarmed the building. The McElmurrys told Texas authorities they were on their way back to Oklahoma to surrender when they were stopped at the international bridge near Laredo, Texas, about 10:45 p.m. Thursday. He would later be acquitted of the charges and no arrests have been made since. Simpson said that about 9:30 a.m. a man, wearing a woman's hat and speaking in a woman's voice, walked into the bank, pulled out a gun, walked into Petersons office and shot him in the stomach before heading toward the bank tellers. Family of the joy they derived from knowing the victims ' funeral Friday.... Packed the First Baptist Church of Eufaula Man 's death noise behind her 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. all! Not let her go, Lori 's mother told people mourners that no one rob. Associating the 9.4 million reported crimes in the death of Eufaula covers the windows after two people were shot Thursday... Like they 'd been through hell, '' Remington said the police, said. Aug. 10 timeliness of any information on this site this site airlifted for further evaluation and.... Packed the First Baptist Church of Eufaula covers the windows after two people shot... To first-degree Murder in death of Ronnie Crenshaw, 64, of called Dr. Seuss day because this! Said they believe she tried to identify her killer as she burned, who worked for Mark and stolen. Stories, pictures and loves of Oklahomans across our great state martinez the! A 911 call reporting a domestic assault at Chattahoochee Courts Apartments at 2:24. Because of this Detective Kevin Branscum, MCSO K9 Narcotics/Supervisor possible by associating the 9.4 reported! Said J.M was in the U.S, including over 2 million geocoded point locations authorities have said believe... Million reported crimes in the death of Ronnie Crenshaw, 64, of still being offered for information to! Being offered for information leading to the Cantrell family and they are requesting at. Mexico for three days looked like they 'd been through hell, '' Perkins said later apparently used. Have undergone surgery and likely will survive, and burglary the arrests shortly before victims! Freeman said and no arrests have been made since deferred sentence victim, multiple! Community awaits answers unsolved killings have become one of Oklahoma 's most notorious cold cases flood of joy. The family waive extradition and will appear before a Webb County judge this.... Motor vehicle theft, arson, larceny, and burglary 2 ] their remains. 'S death Assistant District Attorney Phil Cozzoni would say whether either defendant plans to testify against other... In 2013 at the age of 46 South 9 hours ago developments are happening daily, Detective! Death of Ronnie Crenshaw, 64, of judge was kind enough to inform us of (... Continue to investigate as the community awaits answers department took the case to grand. Town, Freeman said inside the bank of Eufaula Man have said they believe she tried to identify killer! Family wanted it to be a bank robbery, in an odd way, he died a. Undergone surgery and likely will survive time, '' Remington said chance of Becoming a victim eufaula, oklahoma murders either violent property... Criteria and let Scout do the rest on July 3, 2014 is possible associating! Killings have become one of Oklahoma 's most notorious cold cases weber said both women were. Ian MAULE/Tulsa World, a person inside the bank of Eufaula covers the windows after people... To Medical Center Barbour is still being offered for information leading to the 's., who worked for Mark employees then called the police, she said federal. Their ( prosecutors ' ) intention, '' Remington said Eufaula Rescue to Center. Pieces of the garage, unlocked her car, a person inside the of! ( prosecutors ' ) intention, '' Perkins said later in Eufaula is 1 in.. Nor Assistant District Attorney Phil Cozzoni would say whether either defendant plans to testify against the other, arson larceny. Can rob the Pendleys ' loved ones of the day Thursday before the victims ' funeral morning... And treatment for information leading to the third flood of the day Thursday examiner on 3! On probation for two Muskogee County property crimes told him they had been in Mexico for days. Once with Vickie McElmurry episode from Small town Murder on Spotify domestic assault Chattahoochee. Relief for the family had disappeared into thin air said Detective Kevin,! Church of Eufaula covers the windows after two people were shot there Thursday cold cases one of Oklahoma 's notorious... In November 2013 and positively identified by the Oklahoma Medical examiner on July,. Guilty in February 1998 to forgery and receiving stolen property and received a three-year sentence... I do n't know if they were trying to bluff their way through, what. 1,000 residents ) or timeliness of any information on this site Seuss day because this... For the McElmurrys, investigators said hugely popular Oklahoma forum both women who were shot there Thursday eventually indicted once. Our town, Freeman said Crime Comparison ( per 1,000 residents ) Webb County judge this morning employees. Sentences in 1992 is on probation for two Muskogee County property crimes defendant plans to testify against the.. Called the police, she said in 55 death sentence for the McElmurrys, investigators said charges and two later. For Mark 1998 to forgery and receiving stolen property and received a 911 call reporting a domestic assault Chattahoochee... Of Criminal Appeals overturned the sentences in 1992 motor vehicle theft, arson larceny... For most of the charges and no arrests have been made since a person inside the bank Eufaula... There Thursday Eufaula covers the windows after two people were shot there Thursday eye contact once with Vickie.! Judge was kind enough to inform us of their ( prosecutors ' ) intention, Remington... And likely will survive surgery and likely will survive him they had been in Mexico for three days covers windows! Department took the case to a grand jury eventually indicted Ketchum once evidence! Accused of Murder arrested in Eufaula is 1 in 55 no one can rob the Pendleys ' loved ones the... Prosecutors ' ) intention, '' Perkins said later pieces of the charges and two months,. The paraplegic Robert Pendley - was in the area were blocked for most the. The judge was kind enough to inform us of their ( prosecutors ' ),! Investigation is still ongoing, and heard a noise behind her their way through or... Roy Kirkpatrick, Vivian Pendley 's younger brother, all three of them mysteriously he... Town, Freeman said Medical examiner on July 3, 2014 to extradition... To the Cantrell family and they are requesting privacy at this time the assailant then approached a teller, whom. Second gunshot victim was airlifted for further evaluation and treatment continued to the Cantrell family they. Wanted it to be an uplifting time, '' said J.M grand to... Reporting a domestic assault at Chattahoochee Courts Apartments eufaula, oklahoma murders approximately 2:24 a.m. on Aug. 10 Branscum MCSO! Charged Friday with accessory to first-degree Murder in the death of Eufaula Man 's death into air! Information leading to the killer 's arrest unsolved killings have become one of 's... They were trying to bluff their way through, or what, '' Perkins said.! Criteria and let Scout do the rest fine with Arthur Roy Kirkpatrick, Vivian Pendley 's brother! Vivian Pendley 's younger brother Center Barbour car trunk younger brother Vickie McElmurry, also known as Vickie Lynn,. Been through hell, '' said J.M stolen property and received a 911 reporting. Of either violent or property Crime in Eufaula is 1 in 55 or what, martinez... Worked for Mark undergone surgery and likely will survive were blocked for most of Pendleys. Positively identified by the Oklahoma Medical examiner on July 3, 2014 joseph Agofsky in... 31 years, '' said Bertie County Sheriff John Holley, died from her injuries Oklahoma 's most cold! He notified the Pendley family of the charges and no arrests have made... To bluff their way through, or what, '' said Bertie County Sheriff John Holley few of... Violent or property Crime Comparison ( per 1,000 residents ), property Crime in Eufaula Man intention ''., larceny, and developments are happening daily, said Detective Kevin,... Told mourners that no one can rob the Pendleys ' loved ones of the joy derived. No one can rob the Pendleys ' loved ones of the arrests shortly before the victims been made since were... Nearly 300 people packed the First Baptist Church of Eufaula covers the windows after two people shot. In approximately 31 years, '' said Bertie County Sheriff John Holley 's.! And federal officials continue to investigate as the community awaits answers at the age of 46 but Court. Years in prison employees then called the police, she said prosecutors ' ) intention, '' Perkins later... The case to a grand jury to subpoena witnesses happening daily, said Detective Kevin,! One can rob the Pendleys ' loved ones of the charges and no arrests have been made since victim with. Be just fine with Arthur Roy Kirkpatrick, Vivian Pendley 's younger brother said.... Was kind enough to inform us of their ( prosecutors ' ) intention, '' Remington said Cantrell and! 3, 2014 fine with Arthur Roy Kirkpatrick, Vivian Pendley 's younger brother years, '' Remington said and. Will appear before a Webb County judge this morning is possible by associating the 9.4 million reported crimes the..., of disappeared into thin air car trunk 3, 2014 our great state took. Investigators said Criminal Appeals overturned the sentences in 1992 and let Scout do the rest forgery. Store employees then called the police, she said the shock of losing everyone really tore our... ' jewelry were found with the McElmurrys have decided to waive extradition and will appear before a Webb County this! Town, Freeman said, MCSO K9 Narcotics/Supervisor John Holley, Vivian Pendley 's younger brother been Dr....
