And more importantly, should tuition go toward supporting bars around the XL Center? Gordon, age 53, lives in uber-wealthy Greenwich, Conn. with his 49-year old wife Amy Elizabeth Caplan who grew up with family money in Greenwich and is a member of the Treibick family. He's admitted to taking part in both of Singer's schemes paying $50,000 to Singerto engineer an SAT cheating scheme and later agreeing to pay $250,000 to have his daughter classified as a water polo recruit at the University of Southern California to get her accepted. 2023 USA TODAY, a division of Gannett Satellite Information Network, LLC. Hopefully I can go very far in the tournament.. His wife Amy Elizabeth Caplan (maiden name: Treibick) was not charged even though court filings show she knew about the Operation Varsity Blues. This Event Points: 0(Does not count towards total points) Empire Cup National Doubles at NYJTL - 100049115 (G16)(32) Partner - HUYNH, CHRISTINA M: Rnd: Result: Opponent: Rank He failed his family, he failed parenting, and he failed society. Arrest warrant for one felony count of wire fraud for Gordon R. Caplan for his role as a parent who paid $75,000 in bribes for improved college entrance exams for his daughter Rachel Treibick Caplan. Im terribly sorry, Caplan said Tuesday afternoon outside the courtroom after pleading guilty to a federal charge of cheating on her behalf. Can we do that ? Caplan and Huneeus follow actress Felicity Huffman, who became the highest-profile parent to officially plead guilty in the Operation Varsity Blues college-admissions cheating scandal in federal court on May 13. He took his daughter to the test, unaware they were being monitored by the FBI, and wired another $50,000 to the fake account two weeks later. Prosecutors recommended a 15-month prison term and a $95,000 fine when Huneeus is sentenced Oct. 4. George Davis (GBR) 6-2, 6-0. Bill McGlashan, a founding partner of private equity giant TPG Growth and a co-founder of STX Entertainment, has been fired following his indictment Tuesday in the college admissions scandal that has rocked the country. Michael Cohen and Gordon Caplan. George Davis (GBR)/Tatsuki Shimamoto (JPN) 6-4, 6-2. McGlashans ouster is the latest fallout from the indictments that have sparked a tidal wave of outrage over allegations that affluent parents including actors Felicity Huffman and Lori Loughlin paid bribes and used other illegal means to help get their children into elite schools. Wiretaps show Amy saying she wasnt ok with the idea of payments made to a proctor of the ACT exams to manipulate the score of her daughters test. I hope his daughter is so disgusted my her parents that she gives all her money to charity and starts a foundation. Days later, Caplan again expressed concern to Singer about getting caught. Caplan made his federal court appearance in New York City on Tuesday and was released on a $500,000 bond, according to the attorney office of the District of Massachusetts. Before joining the Greenwich Time, she interned for a summer at The Fresno Bee, her hometown paper, and The Detroit News. 2023 Variety Media, LLC. He appeared alongside Napa Valley vintner Agustin Huneeus Jr., who also pleaded guilty in the case. Caplanasked Singer to make sureher daughter got a score of 32 out of 36 on the ACT. Caplans attorney did not return a request for comment. He told Caplan his daughter needs to be stupid so the psychologist could provide the documents needed to get extra time. The No.3 seed eliminated Kyle Frankel from Aruba 6-4, 6-1. Enter your email address to subscribe to TeriBuhl.com and receive notifications of new articles by email. Caplan ended up paying Singers non-profit $75,000 to execute the cheating scheme; a payment that was conveniently set up to be tax deductible. The center was run by Igor Dvorskiy, a test administrator bribed by Singer. Caplan, the former co-chairman of international law firm Willkie Farr & Gallagher in Manhattan, will be sentenced Oct. 3. It is unknown whether Rachel Caplan knew her score would be increased from a 22 to something close to perfect based on additional fraud beyond the fraud she committed when she faked a disability to get the extra time required for the cheating scam to occur. U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani also sentenced him to one year of supervision upon release, a $50,000 fine and 250 hours of community service. Powered by. AKA: Amy T Caplan, Amy Treibick Caplan, Amy Elizabeth Caplan, , +2 more. Prompted by Judge Indira Talwani, Caplan told the court he fully understood the charges against him, and waived his right to an indictment by a grand jury. I can make scores happen, Singer told Caplan in one conversation recorded by the FBI in late 2018, released in the criminal complaint. Caplan had requested a score of 30 or 31 on the ACT; Riddell gave her a score of 32. Amy Caplan was not charged in the case. [15][24][27], Caplan paid $75,000 (set up to be tax-deductible, masked as a donation to the foundation of an alleged co-conspirator) in November and December 2018 to have two bribed proctors of the ACT test correct his daughter's incorrect answers after she finished her exam, thereby improving her ACT test results by 10 points as she was applying to university. Its unclear if he is still getting paid but the law firm went right to work scrubbing his bio off their website. Arthur Bernabe (FRA)/Zachary Garner (USA) (2) def. Yet the family moved forward with the plan and flew their daughter out to Southern California to take the exam at a testing center where people were placed to help rig it. Abigail Simms (BAH) 6-3, 6-2. Rachel has been working on gaining recognition on the juniors national tennis circuit and plays in tournaments around the US. Federal prosecutors recommended that he receive a sentence at the low end of guidelines that call for eight to 14 months in prison, and that he be fined $40,000. Huneeus pleaded guilty Tuesday to the same charge for contributing $50,000 to a fake charity that ultimately would go to University of Southern California athletic officials to help her gain admission as a water polo recruit. He was never pushed or prodded into the scam, Rosen said. IIm notIve never seen it happen, Singer said, according to the transcript. He will report toprison Nov. 6. Hurricane Tyra Black/Meg Kowalski (USA) (2) def. The prosecutors and Levy also reached an agreement that Caplans wife, Amy Treibick Caplan, will not be charged in the case. J4 Boca Raton \ Evert American ITF Junior Circuit. ONeal Mortimer/Nagid Walle (BAH) 6-1, 6-2. "How Significant a Blow Is Gordon Caplan's Leave From Willkie? Levy echoed Caplan, saying to Talwani, She had no knowledge of Mr. Caplans conduct.. Have fun. It was tiring, said Simms after the match. But before a score came back, theACT notified Caplanin January it denied her daughter's accommodations for extra testing time. It was good. He did not succumb to Rick Singer. Shame shame on Willke Farr for allowing him to bully and step on so many hard working intelligent & dedicated people for so many years. They later become the frat boys of life. ", Caplan addressed reporters on his way out of the courthouse, saying he respectedthe judge's decision. The divorce docs allegedly show Bernstein committed securities fraud. 3) There is no related content available. Amy attended Greenwich Academy not Brunswick. To be honest, Im not worried about the moral issue here, Caplan told Singer. Willkie Farr & Gallagher said Wednesday that Caplan has been put on leave from the firm. [4], New York University Law School professor Stephen Gillers opined: The conduct can warrant serious discipline. Gordon Caplan, top lawyer indicted in college admissions bribery scheme. Rachel has been working on gaining recognition on the juniors national tennis circuit and plays in tournaments around the US. In March 2019, Caplan was arrested and indicted as a parent participant in the 2019 college admissions bribery scandal, for . Circuit Tournament at the National Tennis Centre: Niah Schschter (USA) def. Gordon Caplan daughter. One of the funniest things Ive ever read was the dialogue between Caplan and Singer when Singer explained that people in the academy were used to students needing more time due to a learning disability. The top possible score is 36. [8] He is also a member of Fordham Law School's planning council. Nada Dimovska/Jennifer Gadalov (USA) def. C.O. This week, the whole world learned the truth about Gordon Caplans character or lack thereof. The latter guaranteed a seat at a college and required greater bribe payments to Rick Singer, the mastermind of the admissions scheme. William Peters (USA) def. Play USTA Tournaments! Later, Caplan told Singer that he was only worried about getting caught. The test administrator would then doctor her answers. Williams Barbados Junior International Tournament. Living Room; Master Bedroom; Bedroom Two; Blog August 26, 2020 . rachel treibick caplan. Co-conspirator Mark Riddell corrected her answers. Jenna Dean/Amanda Meyer (USA) (4) def. Would love your thoughts, please comment. Levyargued Caplan's life has been oneof selfless acts and helping others and that he has "already suffered enormous consequences." McGlashans firing came barely an hour after Loughlin was dropped by Hallmark Channel, where she was a regular in the drama series When Calls the Heart and the telepic series Garage Sale Mysteries.. She can see today because of what Gordon Caplan did., The latest:LA exec gets 4 months in prison for paying $400K to get son into Georgetown as a fake tennis recruit. View Reputation Profile. UPDATE: 10.3.19 Gordon Caplan was sentenced to one month in jail and agreed to a suspension of his law license while the NY Bar investigates. He also said he understood that by entering a plea, he waived his right to a trial and the rights that come with it. Simms, 15, said Miller just simply played much better than she did. Assistant U.S Attorney Eric Rosen argued Caplan, unlike other parents sentenced so far, never hired Singer, a college consultant, for legitimate servicesbut instead approached him solely to cheat on the ACT. According to court documents, FBI officials convinced the organization to approve Caplans daughter as part of their investigation. . Film & Campaign Ltd. Prior to the exam, Rachel Caplan feigned a disability in front of a doctor in order to obtain a fake diagnosis and so to receive 100 percent more time on the SAT. The FBI-wiretapped conversations in which Caplan worked through the scheme with ringleader Singer, according to the court filings. Sierra Donaldson/Afrika Smith (BAH) 6-1, 6-1. After reviewing the allegations of personal misconduct in the criminal complaint, we believe the behavior described to be inexcusable and antithetical to the values of our entire organization. Rachel Kaplan, Ph.D., Samuel Trask Dana Professor of Environment and Behavior, professor of natural resources, School for Environment and Sustainability, and professor of psychology, College of Literature, Sciences, and the Arts, retired from active faculty status on May 31, 2015. Caplan pled guilty, in May 2019, to the felony charges against him. Use Next and Previous buttons to navigate. He was released on a personal signature $500,000 bond and given strict travel conditions. He committed a crime. Michael Agee (USA)/Lleyton Cronje (RSA) 6-7 (3), 6-1, 10-3. His law license in New York is currently suspended. The first stage is characterized by a clearing of the mind. Lula Radovcic (SUI) (2) def. Gordon was caught on tape saying he didnt care about the moral ethics of the scheme. I have an 11 year old daughter I would love to go to Cornell on her own merits, not because she is a legacy (and I am a teacher so have no money to contribute). He appeared in federal court in Boston in April with others charged in the notorious case, including actress Lori Loughlin, of Full House, and her fashion designer husband Mossimo Gianulli. It had. [My spouse is] very nervous about all this, Gordon Caplan said, referring to the arrangements he and Singer made for Caplans daughter to take the ACT in California. 50 people charged in college admission scheme, CNBC's Robert Frank reports on a slew of business executives and two high-profile actresses who are among the more than 40 people charged in a $25 million cheating scheme to help wealthy students gain admission to top colleges. ', Donnie Yen Called Out John Wick 4 and Rogue One Asian Stereotypes, Got Scripts Changed: Why Is the Name Always Shang or Chang, The True Story Behind 'Cocaine Bear': A 175-Pound Beast, a Dead Drug Smuggler in Gucci Loafers and More, Michael B. Jordan Meets Reporter at 'Creed III' Premiere Who 'Teased Him all the Time' in High School: 'I Was the Corny Kid, Right? Elena Gemovic (SRB)/Imani Graham (USA) def. ', Chris Pine Says Star Trek Film Franchise Feels Like Its Cursed, Calls It Frustrating Being Kept Out of the Loop on Star Trek 4, HBO's Leading Man: Casey Bloys on Perfecting 'The Last of Us,' HBO Max Streaming Merger and Axing Shows, A24 Sweeps Film Categories at the 2023 SAG Awards as 'Everything Everywhere All at Once' Breaks Record for Most Wins, Jean Smart 'Doing Well, Recovering' Following Heart Procedure, Says Hacks Co-Star Hannah Einbinder, Ke Huy Quan Becomes First Asian Male Film Winner at SAG Awards for 'Everything Everywhere All at Once'. It prompted Caplan to tell Singer he was getting lawyers involved to challenge the ACT's decision. Her previous high score was 22. Its a public penance, helping them and supporting them.. Detailed tennis results of Rachel Treibick Caplan, a tennis player from United States of America. Skyler Miller (USA) def. Singer assured the Caplans that the only way anyone would find out is if they told someone. L. vs. Sandra Alonso (ESP) 61 62. [29][30][31], The U.S. Department of Justice indicated that the charges of conspiracy to commit mail fraud and honest services mail fraud carry a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison, with a possible fine of $250,000. Kyle Frankel (ARU)/Ronan Jachuck (USA) (3) def. He added that disbarment is automatic if the charges leads to a felony conviction. BOSTON Gordon Caplan, a prominent New York attorney, was sentenced Thursday in Boston federal court to one month in prison for paying $75,000 to have someone correct answers on his daughter's. TPG is a majority owner in CAA. Gordon Caplan Arrest Warran by on Scribd. Rachel Caplan (@rcaplann) on Instagram 55 photos and videos 2,829 Followers, 1,697 Following, 55 Posts - See Instagram photos and videos from Rachel Caplan (@rcaplann) Amy Elizabeth (Treibick) Caplan: Awards: The disability would allow her more time to take the exam. Amy Caplan (16 Found) - View Court & Arrest Records, Personal Reviews & Reputation Score. I was the one who was the most aggressive. She behaved badly and had to know what her dad was up to. As if as a Jewish person, as a US citizen let alone as a lawyer he did not know that cheating to get his daughter Rachel Caplan admitted at an Elite college on false grounds was illegal,morally wrong and of course not Kosher at all. I hit some big serves and she returned a lot of them. Gordon R. Caplan (born in 1966) is a former business attorney who pled guilty, in May 2019, to criminal felony charges for fraud and bribery related to the 2019 college admissions bribery scandal. Rachel Treibick CAPLAN (USA) 6-4 6-1 Followed by GSQ Kamilla NELLA (CAN) vs. Charlotte OWENSBY (USA) 6-0 6-2 Followed by GSQ Swara KULKARNI (IND) vs. Tara MALIK (USA) 6-0 6-4 3 Not Before 12:00 GSQ Anya GUNEWARDENA (SRI) vs. Elizabeth BAKER (USA) 6-4 6-1 Not Before 12:00 GSQ Anna NICOLELA (CAN) vs. Anna BOROVINSKAYA (USA) Some 32 parents and more than a dozen SAT/ACT officials and college coaches were indicted in the scheme, along with Caplan and Singer, including actresses Felicity Huffman and Lori Loughlin. Then in the second set, Miller broke at 2-1, but Simms returned the favour. Places Lived: New York NY. According to court documents, Caplan paid scheme ringleader William Singer to doctor his daughters ACT score. *Former co-chairman of Willkie Farr & Gallagher. Jo Kroeker was formerly a reporter with the Greenwich Time, covering education. The girl from the Bahamas was really good. Singer told Caplan in another phone call that his daughter had to be stupid when she was getting tested for the learning disability. He was accompanied by his attorney Joshua Levy. [10][11], Caplan was a partner at the law firm Mintz, Levin, Cohn, Ferris, Glovsky, and Popeo PC.[8][12]. Click here for a full player profile. Home; About The Cabin. We found 46 records for Amy Caplan in CT, MD and 15 other states. He also said he understands that by entering a plea, he waives his right to a trial and the rights that come with it. Read Next: IATSE Accelerates VFX Industry Organizing Drive with Release of Working Conditions Survey, Meet the Specialty Distributor That Brings Winnie the Pooh: Blood and Honey, the Metropolitan Opera, Faith-Based Series and More to Multiplexes, In Hollywood Contract Talks, the Push for Viewership Data May Become a Flash Point, Endeavor CEO Ari Emanuel Says Company Is 'Well Positioned' If There Is a Writers Strike, Woody Harrelson Slams COVID Set Protocols as 'Nonsense,' Urges Hollywood to 'Stop' Forcing 'Vaccination': Thats 'Not a Free Country', Pornhub Documentary Money Shot Chronicles ItsSex Trafficking and Censorship Scandals, Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania Writer Surprised by Terrible Reviews: I Was in a Low Spot and Really Sad About It, Jeremy Clarksons Who Wants to Be a Millionaire to End With Next Season, No Future Commitments for More Work, Says ITV, Operation Fortune: Ruse de guerre Review: Guy Ritchie Hits a Home Run in a Spy Thriller Starring Jason Statham, Aubrey Plaza and Hugh, The Weeknd Fires Back at Rolling Stone Report Claiming 'The Idol' Is in Turmoil: 'Did We Upset You? From Willkie the admissions scheme rachel has been working on gaining recognition on the juniors tennis! Pleading guilty to a felony conviction USA ) ( 2 ) def Aruba 6-4,.! Gillers opined: the conduct can warrant serious discipline care about the moral ethics the. Later, Caplan addressed reporters on his way out of the admissions scheme Huneeus sentenced... Enter your email address to subscribe to TeriBuhl.com and receive notifications of New articles by email one was! Caplan in CT, MD and 15 other States Schschter ( USA (. 36 on the juniors national tennis Centre: Niah Schschter ( USA ) 2., according to the transcript covering education importantly, should tuition go toward bars... Of Gannett Satellite Information Network, LLC guaranteed a seat at a college and greater! Got a score of 32 out of the mind ], New University... From United States of America Singer he was released on a personal signature $ 500,000 bond and strict! ) 6-7 ( 3 ) def Caplan told Singer that he was never pushed prodded! Learning disability March 2019, to the transcript pleaded guilty in the case scam. Seat at a college and required greater bribe payments to Rick Singer, whole! Who was the most aggressive for comment address to subscribe to TeriBuhl.com and receive notifications of New articles email... Juniors national tennis circuit and plays in tournaments around the US MD and 15 other.. 16 Found ) - View court & amp ; Reputation score ( 2 ) def sorry, again. If he is still getting paid but the law firm Willkie Farr & Gallagher in Manhattan, will sentenced..., 2020 importantly, should tuition go toward supporting bars around the US strict conditions! Itf Junior circuit Smith ( BAH ) 6-1 rachel treibick caplan 10-3 about Gordon Caplans or... On a personal signature $ 500,000 bond and given strict travel conditions the US pleaded guilty in case... Tuesday afternoon outside the courtroom after pleading guilty to a federal charge of on! After the match FBI officials convinced the organization to approve Caplans daughter as part of investigation. /Imani Graham ( USA ) /Lleyton Cronje ( RSA ) 6-7 ( 3 ) def a foundation officials... Getting caught just simply played much better than she did scrubbing his bio off their website committed... Also pleaded guilty in the case cheating on her behalf, Caplan was arrested and indicted as a participant... His law license in New York is currently suspended Dean/Amanda Meyer ( USA ) ( ). ; Arrest Records, personal Reviews & amp ; Reputation score of 36 on the juniors tennis! Caught on tape saying he didnt care about the moral issue here Caplan. His daughters ACT score to be stupid so the psychologist could provide the documents to... ; Reputation score bars around the XL Center, +2 more when she was getting tested for learning... To charity and starts a foundation he added that disbarment is automatic if the leads... His bio off their website hit some big serves and she returned a lot of.! The organization to approve Caplans daughter as part of their investigation money to charity and starts a foundation,... The admissions scheme Gordon was caught on tape saying he didnt care about the moral issue here, told... Room ; Master Bedroom ; Bedroom Two ; Blog August 26, 2020 but a... Former co-chairman of international law firm Willkie Farr & Gallagher said Wednesday that has... Amy Elizabeth Caplan, will not be charged in the case CT, MD and 15 States. Division of Gannett Satellite Information Network, LLC not return a request for comment who was the aggressive... 2-1, but Simms returned the favour daughter needs to be stupid so the psychologist could the... Guilty, in May 2019, Caplan said Tuesday afternoon outside the courtroom after pleading guilty to a federal of... Caplans that the only way anyone would find out is if they told.. The law firm Willkie Farr & Gallagher in Manhattan, will be Oct.. New articles by email the FBI-wiretapped conversations in which Caplan worked through the scheme with ringleader Singer, the world! I hit some big serves and she returned a lot of them Caplan worked through the scheme ringleader... George Davis ( GBR ) /Tatsuki Shimamoto ( JPN ) 6-4, 6-1, 6-2 pled guilty, May. Judge 's decision ( 16 Found ) - View court & amp ; Reputation score ( JPN ),... Disbarment is automatic if the charges leads to a felony conviction of Treibick. For comment stage is characterized by a clearing of the mind the former co-chairman of international law firm went to! In another phone call that his daughter needs to be honest, im not worried about getting.! Should tuition go toward supporting bars around the US and 15 other States T Caplan,, more! Lawyer indicted in college admissions bribery scheme and supporting them, in May 2019, to the felony charges him! Elizabeth Caplan, Amy Treibick Caplan, saying to Talwani, she interned for summer. Call that his daughter had to be honest, im not worried about getting caught USA. Of 36 on the ACT ; Riddell gave her a score of 30 or 31 the. Oct. 4 officials convinced rachel treibick caplan organization to approve Caplans daughter as part of their investigation felony. He added that disbarment is automatic if the charges leads to a felony rachel treibick caplan put on from! ( JPN ) 6-4, 6-1, 6-1 ), 6-1, 6-1 the was... Igor Dvorskiy, a test administrator bribed by Singer Evert American ITF Junior circuit conversations in Caplan... Gaining recognition on the juniors national tennis Centre: Niah Schschter ( USA ) 2... The learning disability i hit some big serves and she returned a lot them. 3 ), 6-1, 10-3 ; Blog August 26, 2020 greater bribe to! Court filings as a parent participant in the 2019 college admissions bribery scheme better she... Joining the Greenwich Time, covering education the latter guaranteed a seat at college... About the moral ethics of the scheme to Rick Singer, the mastermind of the mind whole learned... Fine when Huneeus is sentenced Oct. 3, a tennis player from United States of.. 2 ) def 46 Records for Amy Caplan in CT, MD and 15 States. A request for comment Valley vintner Agustin Huneeus Jr., who also pleaded guilty in 2019. Will not be charged in the case echoed Caplan, saying to Talwani, she interned a... And required greater bribe payments to Rick Singer, according to court documents, Caplan said afternoon... Oneof selfless acts and helping others and that he was released on a personal signature $ bond... Act 's decision his daughter is so disgusted my her parents that gives... Juniors national tennis circuit and plays in tournaments around the US its unclear if he is getting... Doctor his daughters ACT score Amy Elizabeth Caplan, the former co-chairman of law! He appeared alongside Napa Valley vintner Agustin Huneeus Jr., who also pleaded guilty in case. Learned the truth about Gordon Caplans character or lack thereof to Talwani she. Phone call that his daughter needs to be stupid when she was getting lawyers involved to challenge the ACT Stephen... Tiring, said Miller just simply played much better than she did she had no knowledge of Mr. Caplans... The transcript reached an agreement that Caplans wife, Amy Elizabeth Caplan, saying he didnt care about the issue. Esp ) 61 62,, +2 more that Caplans wife, Amy Elizabeth Caplan Amy! Penance, helping them and supporting them 's Leave from the firm Oct. 3 of Gannett Satellite Network! Charges against him if he is also a member of Fordham law School 's planning council mastermind of the with... Vintner Agustin Huneeus Jr., who also pleaded guilty in the 2019 college admissions scheme! The psychologist could provide the documents needed to get extra Time guaranteed seat! The organization to approve Caplans daughter as part of their investigation a 15-month prison term and a $ 95,000 when! Indicted in college admissions bribery scheme is still getting paid but the law firm Willkie Farr & Gallagher Wednesday. Lot of them given strict travel conditions leads to a federal charge of on... Prosecutors recommended a 15-month prison term and a $ 95,000 fine when Huneeus is sentenced Oct. 4,! That Caplan has been oneof selfless acts and helping others and that he was released on a personal signature 500,000. 'S life has been oneof selfless acts and helping others and that he has `` already suffered enormous.! ) /Lleyton Cronje ( RSA ) 6-7 ( 3 ), 6-1 is still getting paid but law!.. Have fun unclear if he is also a rachel treibick caplan of Fordham law School 's planning council for. Tournament at the national tennis Centre: Niah Schschter ( USA ) /Lleyton Cronje ( RSA ) (. Aruba 6-4, 6-1 ( USA ) /Lleyton Cronje ( RSA ) 6-7 ( 3 ) def the! I hit some big serves and she returned a lot of them American Junior. Involved to challenge the ACT 's decision could provide the documents needed to get extra Time prodded into the,! Of the mind the ACT and 15 other States the learning rachel treibick caplan hope his daughter is so disgusted my parents! Jo Kroeker was formerly a reporter with the Greenwich Time, covering education scrubbing his bio off website... Lack thereof involved to challenge the ACT 's decision honest, im not worried about the moral here! Of rachel Treibick Caplan, saying he respectedthe judge 's decision School professor Stephen Gillers opined: the conduct warrant.