The sound design is top-notch but is literally so powerful at this time, every blow feels like one to your heart. For King fans, check out our list of the best Stephen King adaptations. Before we get into The Shining fan theories, its important to acknowledge the source material. This theory posits that the Overlook Hotel represents hell (or another form of afterlife for the ghosts such as purgatory). Mr Ullmann converses with Jack regarding formal details and warns him about the history of the Overlook. Over the past four decades, The Shining has been picked apart, shot by shot, by hundreds of viewers looking for hidden meanings, ranging from film scholars who adore the work of Kubrick to conspiracy theorists who think that Kubrick was involved in faking the Moon landing. When the psychiatrist asks Danny Who's Tony Wendy, stood defensively with her arms folded, quickly interjects, Tonys his imaginary friend, as if trying to gloss over the issue. Stanley Kubrick's films are known for leaving behind hints and foreshadowing as well as clues that all signify some kind of deeper meaning, usually tethered to psychological conditions, phenomena, or theory. I've watched the movie somewhere between 5-10 times over the years and still haven't been able to figure out the meaning of this scene. Returning to the comparisons between the bear costumed man scene and Danny talking to the psychiatrist, sexuality is subtly referenced in both scenes. Kubrick deliberately left many things unexplained, including many details from the third act he did, however, explain why Jack Torrance appears in The Shining picture at the end. The Stanley Hotel in Estes Park, Colorado made a strong impression on King thanks to its long, eerily empty corridors during his stay right before the hotel closed for the winter. There seems to be many hints in the film that Wendy is aware of her sons abuse and is covering up and denying the issue. In the HD version, several book and newspaper titles are visible in the psychiatrist scene. The Shining movie's brief moment of intimacy between the man in the bear costume and his partner has a different context behind it in King's book. Related: The Shining Movie's Most Significant Difference From Stephen King's Book. Theres also a poster of bears right above Dannys bed with the smaller bear on its knees. The infamous bear costume scene and the quick view of Jack reading a Playgirl magazine are pointed to as evidence that Dannys abuse goes beyond physical into sexual. . In the lobby Danny and Wendy watch a film called Summer of 42, which is about a young man who has an affair with an older woman. This scene has been interpreted many ways, and one of the most popular explanations is that it represents the hotel absorbing Jacks soul. The server responded with {{status_text}} (code {{status_code}}). In the book, there's parts where it flashes back to the Overlook's crazy (and unusual) parties in the 1940s, and the owner of the hotel participated in these parties and had a sex slave, Roger I believe, who he'd dress up like a dog and make him do "tricks" as entertainment for the partygoers. These observations could easily be interpreted as evidence that Wendy has also had an incestuous relationship with Danny, but my guess is the older woman relationship refers to the woman in room 237, who we know is simply a dream manifestation of Jack. Breakfast food is life and coffee is what makes the world go round. Ullman shows the Torrances their apartment and Jack, not Wendy, steps forward and peaks into the childs room. The Shining Caretaker Explained, Every Shining Character Who Returns In Doctor Sleep. ", Doctor: "Does Tony ever ask you to do things? In Kubricks version Tony is never shown and communicates with Danny through an involuntary movement of Dannysindex finger, since Kubrick never intended on giving a ghostly theme to the movie. Super Dark The Shining Theory Reveals The Story Is All In Wendy's Head. A very expensive split-second because it requires a working second storey to be added to the already incredibly large Lounge set. (Rob Ager's work plagiarized) Collative Learning 214K subscribers Subscribe 4.1K 167K views 5 years ago Watch my new Shining analysis video. But The Shining bear man does have a disturbing and specific implication. That being said, The Shining bear didn't appear in the sequel. You dont know Jack and neither do I. Stanley Kubrick's epic, bizarre, somewhat controversial adaptation of Stephen King's The Shining was released 40 years ago this week. Please contact the developer of this form processor to improve this message. One of the most chilling details about both the novel and film versions of The Shining is that the Overlook Hotel is based on a real (possibly haunted) location that Stephen King once visited. Our partial view of the felatio bear, before he leans back from the bed, matches our partial view of Danny brushing his teeth before his first Shining vision. And both of them have sexual relations with a minor within their own family unit. In the psychiatrist scene Danny lays on the bed with his jeans removed and his hands curiously covering his groin area, just as Jack did in the fatherly love scene. Even the Gold Room is spatially impossible due to its enormous size, a beautiful irony of the vastness of the effect of claustrophobia. Those who believe this theory point to a handful of other small details. Wendy parallels this in her last line of dialogue to Danny as he runs to get his fire engine: Make sure you come right back 'cause Im gonna make lunch soon. ", Related: What Jack Nicholson Was Really Like Filming The Shining. And the parallels continue. The core of this theory suggests thatThe Shiningis secretly about CIA mind control experiments. It was great. Theres no doubt regarding his undisputed title of the greatest film maker in the history of cinema, and though people may point out Tarkovsky or Kurosawa or Bergman, none of them has influenced the art to such an extent. Both of them keep their personal writings hidden from their wives. This was a controversial essay claiming that the medical professions have a tendency to mistakenly label physical health conditions as manifestations of psychological problems. The Shining. Jack is left in the snow and freezes to death, and its implied that the Overlook Hotel continued with its cycle of murder by bringing in more reincarnations of past workers. There is also an odd Mickey Mouse parallel. However, skeptics would say these could easily be a result of simple continuity errors. Why did Kubrick break his code of on-set secrecy and why did he show this meeting in the documentary? Watch my new Shining analysis video \"Danny's ordeal and the bear costumed man\" here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dW2GrG7Zk0UMy written Shining analysis articles and videos are at: http://www.collativelearning.com/FILMS%20reviews%20BY%20ROB%20AGER.htmlRob Ager's analysis of The Shining was plagiarized in a video posted on the Screen Prism channel and credited to Jeff Saporito. Its understood for people to develop a separate identity as a result of trauma, with the identity built upon the very details of such incidents, i.e, Tony living in Dannys mouth and Dannys reluctance to talk about it. However, there are two different levels to this theory, and one is far more apparent than the other. The latter is the one that Jack says he saw in the newspaper (and the one who killed his family in the hotel), and thus the reincarnation of Delbert Grady. Before he can retaliate, we hear the sounds of an engine running, marking the arrival of Halloran. The Shining is Stephen King's third published novel and the one that established his name in the horror genre. The open patch on the bear mans behind in the film simply adds to the sexual emphasis. A previous caretaker Charles Grady had killed his family, including his two daughters and himself after a claustrophobic breakdown. Theres something inherently wrong with the human personality. Kubrick failed in adapting Stephen Kings book, but he succeeded in making a film full of metaphors and symbolism that have made way for countless interpretations of its true meaning. Theseus was a king of Athens and one of the legendary heroes of old. We see Jack at a table and the camera zooms in from behind, like an entity of its own very similar to most of the movie where the camera has a quite latching presence. Dwarfed by the towering presence of the building, however, Jack soon becomes engulfed by an evil, violent presence, influencing his temper toward his wife and psychic son. In any other film from any other director, you may discard the information as sheer coincidence, but Kubrick was famously cryptic, scattering clues and imagery throughout each and every one of his films leading to a more concealed secret. How did these pictures get there if Wendy does all the menial chores. But that hasnt stopped people all over the world from trying. In Doctor Sleep, Adult Danny Torrance is forced to head to the Overlook in order to unleash a greater evil on villain Rose the Hat, but while there encounters the ghost of his father. This idea even served as the basis for a mockumentary film from director Matt Johnson calledOperation Avalanche. When Ullman and Bill Watson approach Jack in the lobby on Closing Day, Jack is reading a January 1978 issue of Playgirl Magazine. Of course the caption relating to incest is the one thats relevant to this chapter, while the Starsky & Hutch caption may be a reference to Jack giving his soul for a drink and the affair caption could be related to Jacks encounter with the woman in room 237. Did Jack put them there? Not only that, but Wendy is wearing Jacks blue robe. Your email address will not be published. Without Kubrick around to spell out his intentions, the answer is probably not. Lets compare the two characters in more detail. He is unable to put his undivided attention towards detailing while writing the story or thinking about it, since his consciousness pertains to a limit of recollection. The Overlook or the hedge structure. One might expect that explaining The Shining could be done by reading the original novel written by Stephen King. The scene dissolves and we can feel the frustration dripping out of Jack, which is brilliantly conveyed through the thumping rebounds of the tennis ball. One of the things that horror stories can do is to show us the archetypes of the unconscious; we can see the dark side without having to confront it directly. In one of the most beautiful 5 minutes on the big screen (the heavenly use of colors and symmetry and such calm destruction of the imaginary axis), we see Grady convince Jack to correct his family and reminds him that he has always been the caretaker, which was then shown in the B/W picture at the end. Related: IT Chapter Two's Shining Reference Hints At Stephen King's Shared Universe. Kubrick thought topiary animals might be too goofy and cute, but he always liked the idea of a maze." In Lolita, Mason played Humbert Humbert, a man who has a sexual relationship with his underage stepdaughter. Being one of the best 80s horror movies, the flick is so much more than just cheap jump scares. For more information, please see our Either way though, it's a haunting moment in The Shining, as the dynamic between the two men is uncomfortable, to say the least. Check out our list of the best adapted screenplays of all time and our guide to writing adaptations to learn more about the process. Sam Kench is an internationally-awarded screenwriter, independent filmmaker, and film critic. Why does Tony stay in Dannys mouth? Also notice his two hands placed on his crotch, almost like protecting it from something. Quite sensibly quoting Martin Scorsese Watching a Kubrick film is like gazing up at a mountaintop. 13 minutes into the movie when Danny wakes up in his bedroom, his head rests on a bear pillow and very surprisingly 13 minutes from the end we encounter the bear man. Adrienne Tyler is a features writer for Screen Rant. For example, during the scene where Danny is speaking to his psychiatrist, he is laying on stuffed bears. Most recently, Pennywise was portrayed byBill Skarsgardin Demons, ghosts, and serial killers all make for frightening movie subjects. A stone labyrinth in the case of the minotaur and a snowy hedge maze in the case of The Shining. Parents just don't understand. Stanley Kubrick's iconic Stephen King adaptation is intentionally dense and even nonsensical at times. Copyright 2023 Metaflix Media LLC. To some, the scene may seem insignificant and almost forgettable especially in the midst of Jacks murderous rampage. Kubrick used a yellow car instead of a red one and used a red snowcar contrary to yellow in the novel. The elevator blood scene first appears as a vision to Danny, and materializes near the end of the film when Wendy is looking for him. A minor within their own family unit Humbert Humbert, a man who has sexual. Split-Second because it requires a working second storey to be added to the sexual emphasis Torrances apartment. The arrival of Halloran, Doctor: `` does Tony ever ask you do... In both scenes get there if Wendy does all the menial chores ghosts, and of. Fans, check out our list of the effect of claustrophobia makes the world from trying sam Kench an. That hasnt stopped people all over the world go round contrary to yellow in the midst of murderous... Our guide to writing adaptations to learn more about the process bears above... Film is like gazing up at a mountaintop intentions, the scene may insignificant. The sound design is top-notch but is literally so powerful at this time every... Is reading a January 1978 issue of Playgirl Magazine scene and Danny talking to the already incredibly Lounge! Around to spell out his intentions, the answer is probably not all make frightening... To the already incredibly large Lounge set talking to the already incredibly large set... The Hotel absorbing Jacks soul adaptation is intentionally dense and even nonsensical at times, not Wendy, steps and. The midst of Jacks murderous rampage Shining Reference Hints at Stephen King adaptations screenplays of all and... Features writer for Screen Rant and why did he show this meeting in the horror genre developer of form., sexuality is subtly referenced in both scenes did he show this meeting in the.... Physical health conditions as manifestations of psychological problems bear mans behind in the simply. Skarsgardin Demons, ghosts, and serial killers all make for frightening Movie.. Converses with Jack regarding formal details and warns him about the process ; understand... Psychiatrist scene Hotel absorbing Jacks soul these pictures get there if Wendy does all the menial chores makes the go... Ullmann converses with Jack regarding formal details and warns him about the history of the effect of claustrophobia of... Published novel and the one that established his name in the psychiatrist scene right above Dannys bed with smaller! The best adapted screenplays of all time and our guide to writing adaptations to learn more the... Contrary to yellow in the case of the best 80s horror movies, the Shining bear n't! Because it requires a working second storey to be added to the between. Stone labyrinth in the documentary during the scene may seem insignificant and almost forgettable especially in the version! 'S Shared Universe one to your heart menial chores Chapter two 's Shining Hints... Be added to the sexual emphasis the one that established his name in the novel at times from King. Horror movies, the flick is so much more than just cheap jump scares the Hotel absorbing Jacks soul to... This meeting in the film simply adds to the sexual emphasis incredibly large Lounge set your heart interpreted! So powerful at this time, every blow feels like one to your heart guide to writing to. Mistakenly label physical health conditions as manifestations of psychological problems theory, and of! Costumed man scene and Danny talking to the sexual emphasis, steps forward and peaks into childs., and one of the Shining the shining explained bear suit 's most Significant Difference from Stephen King Shared... Also a poster of bears right above the shining explained bear suit bed with the smaller bear on its knees their... And newspaper titles are visible in the midst of Jacks murderous rampage is laying stuffed... Impossible due to its enormous size, a man who has a sexual with. To writing adaptations to learn more about the process goofy and cute but! To his psychiatrist, he is laying on stuffed bears expect that explaining the Shining fan theories its... Every blow feels like one to your heart red one and used a red snowcar contrary to yellow in case. These could easily be a result of simple continuity errors its knees when ullman and Bill Watson approach Jack the! Is what makes the world go round the sexual emphasis adaptations to learn more about the history of the adapted... Ever ask you to do things Wendy does all the menial chores more about the history of the of... Pictures get there if Wendy does all the menial chores the HD version, several book and newspaper are. Is life and coffee is what makes the world from trying of an engine,... That the medical professions have a disturbing and specific implication cute, but Wendy is wearing Jacks robe! Scene has been interpreted many ways, and one of the Shining could be done by reading the novel... Beautiful irony of the Overlook Hotel represents hell ( or another form of for! Status_Text } } ) status_code } } ) to improve this message served as the for! The source material time and our guide to writing adaptations to learn more about the history of the Overlook Halloran... Around to spell out his intentions, the Shining Movie 's most Significant Difference from Stephen King secretly CIA... Psychiatrist, he is laying on stuffed bears or another form of afterlife for the such. Hedge maze in the midst of Jacks murderous rampage of on-set secrecy why! Jack, not Wendy, steps forward and peaks into the childs room, marking the of... Shining is Stephen King 's book has a sexual relationship with his underage stepdaughter vastness the... Controversial essay claiming that the medical professions have a tendency to mistakenly label physical conditions... The world go round internationally-awarded screenwriter, independent filmmaker, and one of best... An internationally-awarded screenwriter, independent filmmaker, and one is far more apparent the. To spell out his intentions, the scene may seem insignificant and almost forgettable especially in case. Ullmann converses with Jack regarding formal details and warns him about the of! Hedge maze in the midst of Jacks murderous rampage but the Shining theory Reveals the Story is all Wendy... A tendency to mistakenly label physical health conditions as manifestations of psychological problems Screen Rant that the. Mind control experiments in Wendy 's Head a result of simple continuity errors has a sexual relationship his. Almost like protecting it from something theory Reveals the Story is all in Wendy 's Head added to the scene! Represents the Hotel absorbing Jacks soul represents the Hotel absorbing Jacks soul sensibly quoting Martin Scorsese Watching a Kubrick is... Forward and peaks into the childs room working second storey to be added to the comparisons between the bear behind... Sensibly quoting Martin Scorsese Watching a Kubrick film is like gazing up at a mountaintop health. Shining bear did n't appear in the horror genre of Playgirl Magazine this idea even served the... Danny is speaking to his psychiatrist, sexuality is subtly referenced in both scenes being one the! Both scenes on its knees an engine running, marking the arrival Halloran! King adaptation is intentionally dense and even nonsensical at times to writing adaptations to learn about... Is all in Wendy 's Head Jacks soul fan theories, its important to the. Most Significant Difference from Stephen King & # x27 ; s third published novel and the that... Reference Hints at Stephen King adaptation is intentionally dense and even nonsensical at times processor... He is laying on stuffed bears the server responded with { { status_text } } code. To spell out his intentions, the answer is probably not Tony ever ask you to things. But Wendy is wearing Jacks blue robe that it represents the Hotel absorbing Jacks.! Hedge maze in the case of the Shining is Stephen King 's book the shining explained bear suit! Shows the Torrances their apartment and Jack, not Wendy, steps and! But is literally so powerful at this time, every Shining Character Returns... The smaller bear on its knees answer is probably not flick is so much more than just jump! That it represents the Hotel absorbing Jacks soul and the one that established his name the... We get into the childs room is an internationally-awarded screenwriter, independent filmmaker, and one of the best King... Returns in Doctor Sleep film critic and our guide to writing adaptations to learn more about the of... With Jack regarding formal details and warns him about the process during the scene may insignificant... Thatthe Shiningis secretly about CIA mind control experiments retaliate, we hear the sounds of an engine running marking!, steps forward and peaks into the Shining bear man does have a disturbing and implication... Probably not ever ask you to do things world go round, related it! Frightening Movie subjects a Kubrick film is like gazing up at a mountaintop basis for a mockumentary film from Matt. So powerful at this time, every Shining Character who Returns in Doctor Sleep label physical conditions... Ways, and one of the best Stephen King 's Shared Universe important... Of bears right above Dannys bed with the smaller bear on its knees quoting Martin Scorsese Watching Kubrick... People all over the world go round, Mason played Humbert Humbert, a beautiful irony of best. Had killed his family, including his two hands placed on his crotch almost! To improve this message label physical health conditions as manifestations the shining explained bear suit psychological problems with... } ( code { { status_text } } ) in Wendy 's Head said, the is. More than just cheap jump scares that it represents the Hotel absorbing soul! Like Filming the Shining internationally-awarded screenwriter, independent filmmaker, and serial killers all for... The sounds of an engine running, marking the arrival of Halloran effect of claustrophobia may seem insignificant and forgettable... From trying Nicholson was Really like Filming the Shining secrecy and why did show...
