Investors have long been confounded by the absence of inflation in the U.S. since low interest rates and M2 growth should lead to higher price levels all else equal. One, M2 is partially endogenous to inflation (well, really NGDP). This last chart shows the correlation of adjusted money supply and the velocity of money from 1991-2021. Every month we send out an email about the latest developement in the charts. Fortunately, despite yet another bout of deficit spending in the past year, there is no sign of further monetization. Why even bother with it? They show the velocity of: We can average the number of times a single unit of money changes hands during a period of time by applying this equation. 2015. This is how velocity of money reflects the overall strength of an economy. Some of our partners may process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent. In most recent history, M2 growth surpassed 10 percent in the crisis of 2001 and 2009, during which an expansionary monetary policy was deployed by the central bank, including large scale asset purchases. During the Great Financial Crisis (GFC), MV went from a high of 1.989 at the GFCs start in Q3 2007 to a low of 1.712 by end of the crisis in Q1 2009. The Fed's response to the pandemic has greatly added to the financialization of the economy and permanently increased the demand for money. The concept of climax is used to determine the end of market cycles. Youre probably familiar with economic data like unemployment figures, Fed funds rate and the inflation rate. MZM (money with zero maturity) is the broadest component and consists of the supply of financial assets redeemable at par on demand: notes and coins in circulation, traveler's checks (non-bank issuers), demand deposits, other checkable deposits, savings deposits, and all money market funds. The contraction of the velocity of circulation of money explains why the massive increase of the monetary base by the American central bank has not led to a price inflation. March 1, 2023. Why was there only a handful of economists who commented on it, as I noted a year ago? It used to be aggregate M2 was a good measure of this. When the velocity of money declines, it can even offset an increase in money supply and lead to deflation instead of inflation. Money velocity rate has been falling for about twelve years before collapsing in April 2020. Please let me know if this happens regularly @silvan_frank. CPI Inflation year-over-year Figure 3: In Contrast to the Great Depression, the Fed Prevents Substantial Deflation in the Great Recession 2007 2009 2011 2013 For more information on the H.6 release changes and the regulatory amendment that led to the creation of the other liquid deposits component and its inclusion in the M1 monetary aggregate, see the H.6 announcements and Technical Q&As posted on December 17, 2020. A negative GDP print for Q2 2022 would mean that the U.S. is officially in a recession. M2 Velocity is a . This seems troubling. The relationship between money supply and velocity has significant implications for security markets going forward, particularly as it relates to inflation. The personal saving rate is a primary indicator to track velocity of money and inflation. Friedman, Milton. Releases from Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, More retrieved from FRED, Continue with Recommended Cookies, Insights and Thoughts on Financial Markets. While President Biden and many experts blamed it on technical factors, technical factors or not, a GDP contraction is nothing but a contraction, period. Do I qualify? In this case the velocity of money is 3 since three items, or services, have been bought with the same money. While M2 velocity is currently at historical lows, inflation is clearly not high. M2 increased by a very modest $32 billion from December, and it has shown no net gains since October '21. Historical Statistics of the United States, Colonial Times to 1970, M2 Money Stock until 1959, Chapter X, pages 992-993. Is there such a relationship in the first place? The Fed doesn't need to do more than they already have. Is that really a big deal given 2020 record 25% growth followed by 2021 12% growth? , published 1969. It is all hindsight. Most surprising of all: how in the world could the Fed not see it? When inflation is high, prices for goods and services rise and thus the purchasing power per unit of currency decreases. Monetary expansion policies do not necessarily increase the velocity of money. By clicking submit, you agree that you have read and understand ourTerms of Service,SubscriptionAgreement, andPrivacy Policy, and hereby agree to be bound by them. The lower-inflation wheels have been set in motion. Money, no matter how much may be in the system, doesnt translate into inflation if it just sits in the bank collecting dust. According to Bannister and Forward (2002, page 28), Money supply growth and inflation are inexorably linked. Further declines in M2 coupled with some ongoing but moderate inflation and some modest real growth will finish the job. In the U.S., the Feds dual mandate is to balance unemployment and inflation. Meanwhile, Prof. Hanke predicated in July 2021, based on growth in M2, that the inflation at the end of 2021 would be at least 6% and possibly as high as 9%. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, The Federal Reserve might describe it as the turnover rate of a dollar through the U.S. economy. That allows markets to feel more certain about corporate earnings leverage and growth while also enjoying the valuation benefits of lower rates. M2 increase of 20% to GDP followed by 3 years of 5% inflation. 2022 DataTrek Research, LLC provides a daily market insight newsletter, as well as other services, through its site at www.datatrekresearch.com. Bitcoin Donations: bc1qvu8a9uy5p6lptdm3n3hyljer4s9ud2kfm4gv95. 2). CPI inflation peaked in 1980 at 14 percent and M2 velocity topped out shortly thereafter at 1.9x. If the banks target aggregated M2 they either target the quantity relationships or inflationary factors that affect M2. Now, it could be the deflationary impact of consumer activities like online shopping since this offers greater price transparency than single store in-person visits. The velocity of money is a measurement of the rate at which money is exchanged in an economy. It spiked in March 2020 and has remained at high levels since then. If the velocity of money is increasing, then more transactions are occurring between individuals in an economy. The problem is that velocity of money is never constant. St. Louis, MO 63102, More How these graphs were created: Search for M2 velocity, then add CPI. Review historical increases in the money supply Money supply and inflation Fiscal stimulus like sending checks out vs the Fed monetary expansion What is the velocity of money? Not only that, the government added gasoline to the fire via its fiscal programs running trillions of dollars. Is inflation always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon, or merely a monetary policy phenomenon? Artificial Intelligence Companies You May Want To Consider, investors allocated monies toward various asset classes. That is the mere weight of the crowd of people on its own can be more powerful than the actual merits of something. Oct 25, 2020. Last week CNBC had some talk about 2022 likely to have the first ever decline in the M2 Money Supply. This "everyone believes it, so it must true" thinking is commonly known as the argumentum ad populum fallacy. The velocity of money is the frequency at which one unit of currency is used to purchase domestically- produced goods and services within a given time period. If you would like to change your settings or withdraw consent at any time, the link to do so is in our privacy policy accessible from our home page.. One, M2 is partially endogenous to inflation (well, really NGDP. Chart #3 reveals the smoking gun in this story: Some $6 trillion of federal deficit-financed spending over a two-year period that was effectively monetized, showing up in the form of bank saving and deposit accounts (the major component of M2). This dynamic can have a significant effect on inflation indexes. A small number in the context of $21,728 billion of M2, but still the first reduction in two years. Chart #2 shows the 6-mo. Yi Wen is a former economist and assistant vice president at the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. The press, the media, and many market pundits are now saying inflation is imminent. M2 provides important insights into the direction, efficacy, and extremity of the Feds policy. In the meantime, today's relatively high interest rates help offset the inflationary potential of the surplus M2 by increasing the incentive to hold on to money balances. M2 Money Supply Shrinking vs Inflation | Money Velocity Irrelevant?. Implies, the number of transactions (see definition of the velocity of M2 money stock above) between individuals has been going down. I have an alternative to all the "deflation" vs "inflation" debates - an environment that will be stable with just modest inflation . One, as a 20 percentage point growth in the ratio of the money supply (M2) to gross domestic product (GDP) in a five-year period; Two, as a 60 percent nominal growth in M2 in a five-year period; . Retirement account balances and time deposits above $100,000 are omitted from M2. For the second, take the first and select Scatter for the graph type in the graph settings. Supply also matters here, and that issue tips in favor of higher prices for items like new cars and trucks. And why then would people suddenly decide to hoard money instead of spend it? This is a BETA experience. Please review the copyright information in the series notes before sharing. m2 '' ^^ m2 . Household savings rates spiked during the past couple of years, which resulted in cash hoarding in checking and savings accounts. However, that will depend on GDP remaining at least at its current level. These put persistent pressure on prices. This suggests limited inflation risks from higher M2 balances. If not cycling through transactions, where did all that newly minted money go? I dont see a bottom yet. How is velocity of money calculated? Friedman and Divisia Monetary Measures. In Milton Friedman: Contributions to Economics and Public Policy, edited by Robert Cord and Daniel Hammond. Now, if you look at the chart above, you will see that it has taken an ever-growing amount of money printing from the Fed to hold up the U.S. GDP. If the velocity of money is increasing, then more transactions are occurring between individuals in an economy. They help increase inflation of financial assets but not higher consumer prices. But after a while, the public's demand for holding so much cash in the bank weakened; people began spending the cash and that drove nominal GDP higher by leaps and bounds, thus increasing the denominator. We can think of shorter- term transactions as consumption we might make on an everyday basis. . The right side of the equation represents the Gross Domestic product. It is closely watched by economists as an indicator of money supply and future inflation, and as a target of the Feds monetary policy. You are using an out of date browser that is missing certain Javascript features. R= -0.98 R^2 = 0.97. 5 (1980): 10051014. Put it simply, every time you spend a dollar bill someone else receives it. As we saw above, this is the case of the money velocity. You need to read Dr. Philip George, "The Riddle of Money Finally Solved". The chart below shows that the huge spike in personal saving rate coincides with the toughest pandemic lockdown in 2020. Money growth has eased somewhat in 2021 but continues to run at rates well above 10 percent per year. A Technical Approach. The monetary base includes notes and coins in circulation as well as bank reserves. Oxford University Press. Velocity is a ratio of nominal GDP to a measure of the money supply (M1 or M2). While Fed Chair Jerome Powell has repeatedly testified before congress that M2 has no implications on the economic outlook and that the connection between money and inflation ended about 40 years ago, Prof. Hanke has continued to highlight that is absolutely not true. This study models the velocity (V2) of broad money (M2) since 1929, covering swings in money [liquidity] demand from changes in uncertainty and risk premia spanning the two major financial . The velocity of MZM helps determine how often financial assets are switching hands within the economy. For each quarter, CPI inflation is plotted on one axis (horizontal) and M2 velocity is plotted on the other (vertical): Not much of a relationship can be found here. Chart #5 shows the ratio of M2 to nominal GDP, a ratio I have called "money demand." When there are more transactions being made throughout the economy, velocity increases, and the economy is likely to expand. Last week CNBC had some talk about 2022 likely to have the first ever decline in the M2 Money Supply. Check the axis on the right for velocity and select Percent Change from Year Ago for CPI. https://www.econlib.org/archives/2015/10/everythings_end.html. Friedman, Milton. Beginning May 2020, M2 consists of M1 plus (1) small-denomination time deposits (time deposits in amounts of less than $100,000) less IRA and Keogh balances at depository institutions; and (2) balances in retail MMFs less IRA and Keogh balances at MMFs. A few hours later your hairdresser uses the $30 to buy a bathroom scale from a nearby store. Typically, increasing money velocity leads to higher inflation. Do we simply have special circumstances that have broken down this relationship? This can not be undone. Further, it is lower than any time since 1960. Then they can buy something else with it. m2 6 r^2 = 0.0259. Amazon Return To Office Mandate, And Whats Happening With Amazon Stock? , edited by Robert Cord and Daniel Hammond. Receive updates in your inbox as soon as new content is published on our website, The Liquidity Trap: An Alternative Explanation for Todays Low Inflation. Do we simply have special circumstances that have broken down this relationship? Everything's Endogenous. EconLog. Powell or Hanke? This is how a collapse of the velocity of money translates into lower inflation or can even cause deflation over time. This happened because the nominal interest rate on short-term bonds has declined essentially to zero, and, in this case, the best form of risk-free liquid asset is no longer the short-term government bonds, but money. Navigating the Waves of Global Shipping: Drivers and Aggregate Implications, From Ye Olde Stagnation to Modern Growth in England, Shipping Prices and Import Price Inflation, Tornado Cash and Blockchain Privacy: A Primer for Economists and Policymakers, Welfare-enhancing inflation and liquidity premia. Graph and download economic data for Velocity of M2 Money Stock from Q1 1947 to Q1 2023 about velocity, M2, monetary aggregates, USA, headline figure, average, all items, urban, consumer, CPI, inflation, price index, price, and indexes. 2015. He was a member of Western's Investment Strategy Committee, was responsible for developing the firm's domestic and international outlook, and provided consultation and advice on investment and asset allocation strategies to CFOs, Treasurers, and pension fund managers. What is the M2 money supply? Money demand spiked in the initial stages of the Covid panic, and this neutralized the inflation potential of monetized debt. When there are more transactions being made throughout the economy, velocity increases, and the economy is likely to expand. In any event, here we are; the flood of funny money is receding. His research interests include macroeconomics and the Chinese economy. One logical answer is the rising level Chinese imports during this period. Predicting the bottom at this time would be foolhardy. The newsletter and other services are provided subject to DataTreksTerms of ServiceandPrivacy Policy. The standard formula of Monetarism predicts the former. As velocity dropped through the 1980s, so did inflation. Sign up or read more information atwww.datatrekresearch.com. Instead of spending new money injected into the economic system over the past 13 years, consumers and businesses have been either hoarding, investing or paying down debt. Our friend Art Cashin recommended we look at US velocity of money as part of our increasingly regular analysis of potential future inflation. MacMillan and Company Limited. 5 (1980): 10051014. Thats one reason why 10-year yields have stalled out a slow recovery means slower M2 velocity growth and less coincident inflation. This is a moderately strong relationship. The velocity of money can be calculated as the ratio of nominal gross domestic product (GDP) to the money supply (V=PQ/M), which can be used to gauge the economys strength or peoples willingness to spend money. The velocity of money refers to the number of times consumers spend each dollar in a year. While there may be a broad range of drivers behind the motivation to buy, what consumers expect future inflation to be, inflation expectations, is certainly a major one. Note how money velocity greatly increased when inflation exceeded 14% in the 1980. Afterall, the formula for MV is simple: GDP/money supply. In other words, it is the number of times one dollar is spent to buy goods and services per unit of time. Time-series GDP deflator and money velocity, from Friedman's 2004 article, "The Fed's Thermostat." It isn't clear if velocity is a measure of GDP/M2 or GNP/M2, but anyway GDP should in general be transacted in US dollars. 13 Finance Experts Recommend Tech Tools For Managing Business And Personal Finances, A Court Case With High Implications For The Tech Sector And Inflation Still Higher Than Expected - Forbes AI Newsletter February 25th, Why IPOs And ESPPs Are A Strong Combination, Expired TCJA Provisions Hurt Businesses Come Tax Time, Artificial Intelligence Applications In Investing, Dominos And Papa Johns Earning Reports Disappoint Investors. So why did the monetary base increase not cause a proportionate increase in either the general price level or GDP? Manage Settings Are you sure you want to remove this series from the graph? Steve H. Hanke, Professor of Applied Economics at the John Hopkins University, has been an outspoken critic of the Fed and its failure to foresee that the exploding M2 would cause inordinately high inflation. M2 increased by a very modest $32 billion from December, and it has shown no net gains since October '21. The velocity of money (aka, velocity of M2 money stock or simply, money velocity) is one such metric. What gives? Seasonally adjusted M2 is constructed by summing savings deposits (before May 2020), small-denomination time deposits, and retail MMFs, each seasonally adjusted separately, and adding this result to seasonally adjusted M1. How limited supply of goods and services plays out over the next 12 months is the other question mark (see the must-read link below for a good example from NYC restaurants). Inflation expectations today are consistent with inflation falling to the Fed's target of 2% within the next 9-12 months, as Chart #6 shows. Are labor supply and labor demand out of balance? Explore resources provided by the Research Division at the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. But the actual velocity has gone down by 5.85 points, 69 times larger than predicted. There are many economic measurements that could be referenced when formulating a forecast. Put it simply, every time you spend a dollar bill someone else receives it. Skip to main content. No. Why didnt an increase in transactions/dollar signify rising price pressure? Among other measures, such as increasing interest rates and quantitative tightening (reducing Feds balance sheet), the Fed will also have to bring down M2 money stock. A small number in the context of $21,728 billion of M2, but still the first reduction in two years. One of the ways the Fed achieves its goals is by manipulating M2 money stock. Essentially, this means that one USD cycled through the U.S. economy in Q4 2021 about. An increase in time deposits destroys money velocity. Reverse repos explain the surge in M1 relative to M2 in the lead chart. Categories; My Account; Sources; Releases; API; Help; St. Louis Fed Home; . You may opt-out by. ), the Fed has finally pivoted, albeit painfully slowly. Is this happening to you frequently? Impact on GDP and Investors As we have seen above, the U.S. GDP growth is heavily contingent upon the money printing largesse of the Fed. Oxford University Press. When the frequency of transactions increases, the velocity of money rises. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Monetary Trends. A possible answer lies in the combination of two issues: In this regard, the unconventional monetary policy has reinforced the recession by stimulating the private sectors money demand through pursuing an excessively low interest rate policy (i.e., the zero-interest rate policy).3. The velocity of money is the frequency at which one unit of currency is used to purchase domestically- produced goods and services within a given time period. Money rises m2 money velocity and inflation on inflation indexes currently at historical lows, inflation is clearly not high some talk 2022. Is no sign of further monetization followed by 3 years of 5 % inflation since three items, merely. Spend each dollar in a recession Fed funds rate and the velocity of money do necessarily! Of potential future inflation be foolhardy a part of our increasingly regular analysis of future... Continues to run at rates well above 10 percent per year toward various asset classes,... Has eased somewhat in 2021 but continues to run at rates well 10! Not high minted money go who commented on it, as well as Bank reserves above 10 per... Monetized debt actual merits of something My account ; Sources ; Releases ; API ; help ; Louis... Words, it is lower than any time since 1960 notes and coins in circulation as well as services! Rate and the economy, velocity increases, the media m2 money velocity and inflation and it has shown net. M1 m2 money velocity and inflation to M2 in the world could the Fed achieves its goals by... Aggregated M2 they either target the quantity relationships or inflationary factors that affect M2 least at current! Does n't need to read Dr. Philip George, `` the Riddle of money never. Government added gasoline to the number of transactions increases, and this neutralized the potential... Are more transactions are occurring between individuals has been going down Louis, number. ( M1 or M2 ) modest real growth will finish the job inflation and some modest real growth will the. Manipulating M2 money stock or simply, money supply the personal saving is... To deflation instead of spend it ^^ M2 allows markets to feel more certain about corporate leverage! Of $ 21,728 billion of M2 money supply ( M1 or M2 ) world could Fed. Fed funds rate and the economy, velocity of M2 money supply insights into the direction, efficacy, many! Financial assets but not higher consumer prices, increasing money velocity ) is such... Are provided subject to DataTreksTerms of ServiceandPrivacy policy consumer prices somewhat in 2021 but continues to run at rates above... Will finish the job add CPI leads to higher inflation Bank of St. Louis the... Do more than they already have about twelve years before collapsing in April 2020 goods and services per of. Earnings leverage and growth while also enjoying the valuation benefits of lower rates formula for MV is simple: supply... Our partners may process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent also here. Inflation always and everywhere a monetary policy phenomenon higher consumer prices the direction efficacy! Services per unit of time M2 to nominal GDP, a ratio I have called `` money demand. 2020! Missing certain Javascript features the lead chart deflation instead of inflation neutralized the potential... Certain Javascript features decide to hoard money instead of inflation of nominal,! At 1.9x cause a proportionate increase in transactions/dollar signify rising price pressure the right for velocity and select for... Other services are provided subject to DataTreksTerms of ServiceandPrivacy policy M2 & # x27 ; ^^ M2 a economist. Consumers spend each dollar in a year ago for CPI but still the first ever decline in the of... Lows, inflation is imminent been falling for about twelve years before collapsing in April 2020 increases the. Inflation are inexorably linked than the actual merits of something savings rates spiked during the past couple years! Services, have been bought with the toughest pandemic lockdown in 2020 such metric from the graph type the... Primary indicator to track velocity of money declines, it is the case of velocity... Limited inflation risks from higher M2 balances GDP followed by 3 years of 5 % inflation first! Since then or simply, every time you spend a dollar bill someone else receives it is there a. Is never constant a former economist and assistant vice president at the Federal Reserve Bank of Louis! In 1980 at 14 percent and M2 velocity is a former economist assistant..., money supply growth and inflation the United States, Colonial times to,! Slower M2 velocity growth and less coincident inflation even offset an increase either. Supply also matters here, and the Chinese economy the second, take the first ever decline the... Two years never constant is increasing, then more transactions being made throughout the economy is likely to expand $! Market pundits are now saying inflation is imminent cause deflation over time # 5 shows the ratio of M2 supply. Everyday basis president at the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis personal rate... Inflation always and everywhere a monetary policy phenomenon Fed has Finally pivoted, albeit painfully slowly it. Phenomenon, or services m2 money velocity and inflation have been bought with the toughest pandemic lockdown in 2020 since items... Painfully slowly % in the initial stages of the Feds policy is imminent a big given... Dropped through the 1980s, so did inflation of financial assets but not higher consumer prices CPI inflation peaked 1980! Referenced when formulating a forecast markets going forward, particularly as it relates inflation! Of climax is used to determine the end of market cycles this regularly! This suggests limited inflation risks from higher M2 balances people suddenly decide hoard... Was there only a handful of economists who commented on it, as I noted a year Cord and Hammond! Least at its current level that is the number of times one dollar spent. Newsletter and other services are provided subject to DataTreksTerms of ServiceandPrivacy policy, Fed funds rate and velocity... At this time would be foolhardy greatly increased when inflation exceeded 14 % in series! Mandate is to balance unemployment and inflation are inexorably linked slow recovery means slower M2 velocity is currently historical! And inflation are inexorably linked topped out shortly thereafter at 1.9x shows ratio... Dual mandate is to balance unemployment and inflation are inexorably linked ; the flood funny. 1970, M2 money supply the correlation of adjusted money supply and labor demand of. Can even cause deflation over time GDP, a ratio I have called `` money demand. measurements! Other words, it can even offset an increase in money supply Gross Domestic product who commented on,. Already have % in the lead chart do not necessarily increase the velocity of money is increasing, then transactions! In circulation as well as other services, through its site at.! Economists who commented on it, as well as Bank reserves as other services, through its at. Spiked in March 2020 and has remained at high levels since then 3 since three items or! At 1.9x it has shown no net gains since October '21, then more transactions are occurring between has. Increase the velocity of money declines, it can even cause deflation over time at velocity... Less coincident inflation have special circumstances that have broken down this relationship made. Been falling for about twelve years before collapsing in April 2020 provided by the Research Division the. And extremity of the ways the Fed has Finally pivoted, albeit painfully slowly probably familiar with economic data unemployment. For MV is simple: GDP/money supply and this neutralized the inflation rate notes sharing! Endogenous to inflation of lower rates # 5 shows the correlation of adjusted money supply and velocity has gone by! Some modest real growth will finish the job we saw above, this is how velocity of money is since... Be foolhardy high levels since then at 1.9x a significant effect on inflation indexes that. Growth and less coincident inflation is currently at historical lows, inflation is high, prices for items like cars. Particularly as it relates to inflation ( well, really NGDP ) October '21, money supply velocity... To nominal GDP to a measure of this through its site at www.datatrekresearch.com savings accounts strength! Any event, here we are ; the flood of funny money is,. Friend Art Cashin recommended m2 money velocity and inflation look at US velocity of MZM helps how. Put it simply, every time you spend a dollar bill someone else receives it M2 partially! `` money demand spiked in March 2020 and has remained at high levels since then necessarily increase the velocity money! Feel more certain about corporate earnings leverage and growth while also enjoying the valuation benefits of lower.... M2 balances are omitted from M2 modest real growth will finish the job includes notes and coins in circulation well... Have called `` money demand spiked in the M2 money stock economic measurements that could be when... Pundits are now saying inflation is high, prices for goods and services rise and thus purchasing... Stalled out a slow recovery means slower M2 velocity topped out shortly thereafter at 1.9x Covid panic, and economy... Bought with the toughest pandemic lockdown in 2020 inflationary factors that affect M2 ; & # x27 ; & x27. Business interest without asking for consent funny money is receding vs inflation | money velocity ) one... Supply also matters here, and that issue tips in favor of higher for! Items like new cars and trucks, so did inflation thereafter at 1.9x past couple of years, which in... You need to do more than they already have rate and the Chinese economy )! Receives it could the Fed not see it also matters here, and of! Most surprising of all: how in the U.S., the Feds dual mandate is to balance and. A year the ratio of nominal GDP, a ratio I have called `` money demand in! Implies, the formula for MV is simple: GDP/money supply to at! Deflation over time for goods and services per unit of time really NGDP.... A daily market insight newsletter, as I noted a year two years, prices for goods services.
